Welcome to our Research and Development Page.
Here we will explain how the wind blowing causes that awful sound
you heard.
The Sound you heard is a wind induced noise. Note how the sound
levels vary as the wind gusts. High rise condominium balcony
railings exposed to coastal winds are more likely to experience wind
induced noise than inland condo balcony railing where the wind is
broken up by the surrounding buildings.
Everything Vibrates, that's the basics. You may not feel it, you may
not see it, but everything vibrates. This is called "Natural
Frequency" its normal and cannot be stopped. Everything has its own
Natural Frequency; Ocean Waves, Wind, even Stone or Concrete Rocks.
Your Balcony Guardrails also have their own Natural Frequency.
Railings noise is caused when the Natural Frequency of the wind
beating against your rails Resonates with your Rails Natural
Frequency creating Resonance Harmonics.
There is additional information available from external links that
will explain some of the terms and behavior discussed here, click on
our Links page for additional information.

What this means in plain English: The wind is not constant ... it
"beats" or blows with a certain frequency, that frequency is
dependent on variables including atmospheric conditions etc. The
result is wind.
The Picture to the left illustrates this nicely, it shows the wind
blowing waves of Wheat.
When the wind strikes your railings at it's own special frequency, the
railings absorb this energy. (they actually absorb and transmit
energy from and to everything that they touch including the
building)
Normally the energy is dissipated and there is no noise. However,
when conditions are right, the wind speed is high enough, or from
the right direction etc., the energy is not dissipated, rather the
two frequencies (the wind frequency and the railing frequency) line
up (get into phase) and reinforce one another. This results in
stronger (greater amplitudenal) vibrations. The end result is that
the railings begin to vibrate harder. This vibration acts just like
an audio speaker and you hear that annoying sound. The chart below
illustrates the phenomena.

The above Graph is for illustration purposes only.
It demonstrates how the two signals can line up, or fall "into
phase" or "out of phase" thereby increasing or decreasing the
strength of the vibration.
The problems associated with calculating the frequencies involved is
that the wind is never a constant and the railings are under the
effect of the attached balcony/building either being damped or
excited.
The Solution.
So we have discussed Natural Frequency, Resonance, Harmonics,
Amplitude and Phase. We now need to discuss the physical properties
that determine Natural Frequency in solids, they are: Stiffness and
Mass.
The Formula for determining Natural Frequency is Fn= (1/2π)√(K/M)
where K is stiffness and M is Mass.

We have tested various methods using Lab View Signal Express
software, accelerometers, and eccentric weight motors running on a
variable speed DC motor controller which allowed us to fine tune the
resonance signals.
The Stiffer something is the higher it's natural frequency, the
Heavier something is the lower its natural frequency. This reveals
two possible solutions to the problem of noisy railings.
1. Increase the mass.
2. Increase the stiffness
1. Increase the mass: This is commonly known as a Mass Damper or
Tuned Mass Damper. The idea is that by increasing the mass it takes
additional energy to begin the harmonic resonance into phase and
that the railings will dissipate the energy before it reaches that
point.
2. Increase the stiffness: This works by raising the natural
frequency of the railing. This increases the ability of the rail to
dampen vibrations as the frequency of phase is shifted higher and
the opportunity of the railing to fall into and out of phase
increases.
Keep in mind we are simplifying things a bit here because there are
so many different variables that can influence the vibration and the
resonance, Wind speed, Wind frequency, the inherent vibrations of
the structure to name a few. We have there fore focused on those
things we can control.
Check our products & services for more information on our solutions,
both alter the stiffness and mass.